Upper Register Performance Soprano Sax - A Question

A question was posed to me last week and as there are many elements of my reply that might be of interest to others I offer the following on this topic.

Question:

I struggle with getting high notes on my soprano sax. Should I change my reed (strength) ?

Reply:

Changing your reed strength may be helpful but just playing a harder reed (I have to assume this is what you mean) will not necessarily be the answer. The soprano sax should not be more ‘difficult’ than other saxophones but its small size means that it may be more critical. Little things will make big differences. Every aspect of your playing technique is ‘under the microscope’ in ways larger saxes do not require to the same degree. This is why prior experience in alto or tenor sax is usually recommended before adding the soprano to your saxophone armoury.

There are many factors that will affect the response and stability of the saxophone upper register, especially on soprano, so a review of them may be useful:

• The embouchure must still be ‘round and supportive’ but not too tight. Playing a stable concert C on the soprano mouthpiece setup alone is a good target (concert Ab for alto, concert Gb for tenor).
• The correct amount of mouthpiece in the mouth is very important – too much in the mouth and the sound and upper register response will suffer, too little and the tone will be dead and both high and low registers will be compromised.
• The airstream used should feel significantly faster for the soprano and if the high notes are unstable you may need to ‘focus’ the air into a smaller yet still energetic stream in order to provide what the upper range notes require.
• The quantity of air used for different registers will need to be varied – higher, shorter tube notes require less (they are easy to overpower) whereas lower, longer tube notes will require a proportionally greater volume of air to fill the tube and stabilise their response.
• Inside your oral cavity the tongue must have a more exaggerated ‘arch’ position than what you use on the alto, tenor or baritone and this arch is closer to the rear of the mouth. This is a bit like saying the vowel sound ‘Eeeeee’
• Your mouthpiece must be in a good tuning position on the cork. If pulled off too far the low notes will not speak properly and high notes will be very flat in pitch and unresponsive. If the mouthpiece is pushed on too far on you might think all is okay - until you check your tuning – when you are likely to find the high register to be extremely sharp and the instrument very out of tune with itself.
• If your mouthpiece tip opening is moderate or narrow then a medium to medium strong reed (strength 2.5 to 3.5 in most brands) is likely to be required in order to provide stability throughout the instrumental range, right up to high F# or G.
• If your mouthpiece tip opening is on the larger side a somewhat softer reed may provide a better match. Too strong and you will find yourself fighting the low register and having to ‘bite’ too hard to make your basic sound.
• Higher baffle mouthpieces (including many jazz style mouthpieces) will be generally brighter and in fact may facilitate upper register playing but may also demand more relaxation in the embouchure and ‘favouring’ downward for pitch. Moderate or lower baffle mouthpieces are generally more stable for intonation and are likely be more manageable throughout the entire range.

As a guide I would suggest that you are in search of a reed strength that provides enough resistance to meet the demands of your properly focused and well-regulated airstream without excess embouchure pressure required.

Success with higher register notes should follow.

The tips and comments above are the result of many years of providing help and advice, my personal interest and study, and the teaching that I have done during my career. I have many colleagues and teachers to thank for sharing their thoughts and suggestions on this and other topics. In addition I am indebted to Woodwind & Reed, Cambridge ( www.wwr.co.uk ) where, in the course of helping customers, many of these concepts have been refined and have proven helpful. 

Thomas Dryer-Beers

Tips on Switching Between Clarinet and Saxophone

Tips on Switching Between Clarinet and Saxophone

from The Single Reed Doctor Column, CASS Article December 2016

In response to a question posed by a member of the Clarinet and Saxophone Society of Great Britain I the reply below. I hope it might also be of interest and helpful for Wind Player Advice readers.

Question:

I play both clarinet and saxophone but find it difficult to move between the two. The sax feels very open, requiring a lot of air, while the clarinet feels tight and pressured. I have recently started playing in shows and need to improve my quick changes between the two. Is there anything I could do to my set-up that would make this easier?

My 'Single Reed Doctory' reply:

This is a very good and multifaceted question and one that I am afraid does not have a quick or straight forward answer. Some players never seem to need help with this. They just ‘get it’ and manage to double sax and clarinet seemingly without much effort. Most players need to examine this question in greater detail and the process of examination should prove useful for anyone wishing to play their best.

You will find examples of equipment intended to make switching between clarinet and saxophone easier but in my opinion this route does not help in the long run as it can obscure the issue. It is fair to say that moderate tip openings and standard chamber mouthpieces are likely to make for easier control of both instruments possible - therefore you may wish to avoid extremes - however, leaving equipment aside - a thorough understanding of the requirements for good playing on each instrument is the best way to develop your control and to achieve a rewarding, characteristic tone on both clarinet and saxophone(s).

The clarinet has a cylindrical bore and all saxophones have conical bores. This central difference contributes to not only how each instrument overblows but how it responds. The reason the sax feels so ‘open’, something quite disorienting to many clarinettists, is that the amount of air required to fill the tube is highly variable depending upon the length of tube in use and the register. The clarinet bore, to many saxophonists, feels quite ‘stuffy’ and resistant - or pressured as you suggest. This is largely due to the more consistent taper dimension of the bore (varying significantly only at the bell) and the requirement of a uniformly higher pressure throughout the entire range of the instrument regardless of the fingered length of the tube.

In my teaching I have used the concept of the Two Q’s when trying to explain this and perhaps you might find this helpful.

• The Quality of the air pressure must remain the same for both instruments, at all times and at all dynamics.

• The Quantity of the air used varies depending upon the range, register, dynamics and resistance of the instruments. This is much more obvious on the sax than the clarinet. Understanding and applying these concepts can transform a players experience.

The mouthpiece used must allow a player to be comfortable whilst utilising the best air support they can provide without requiring an excess of embouchure pressure. The appropriate resistance to a well supported air column is not just to be found at the embouchure surrounding the mouthpiece and reed but the airstream is also focused and shaped in the oral cavity via the position of the tongue. In my experience the tongue is uniformly arched higher at the back of the oral cavity on the clarinet and the progressively positioned slightly further forward in the cavity as one moves to saxophones and larger clarinets.

Time spent learning how the ‘flick the switch’ and instantly apply the appropriate blowing techniques to each instrument will mean that a player can more quickly and consistently achieve a more satisfying and convincing performance even when switching in a show environment.

----------------

The tips and comments above are the result of many years of providing help and advice, my personal interest and study, and the teaching that I have done during my career. I have many colleagues and teachers to thank for sharing their thoughts and suggestions on this and other topics. In addition I am indebted to Woodwind & Reed, Cambridge ( www.wwr.co.uk ) where, in the course of helping customers, many of these concepts have been refined and have proven helpful. 

Thomas Dryer-Beers

The Importance of the Air Stream in Wind Playing

The Importance of the Air Stream in Wind Playing

In my teaching and throughout my time advising in the retail shop environment the topic of good air support has always been very important. I certainly did not know enough nor pay enough attention to developing good breathing and support habits when I was younger and many other players share the same difficulties and frustrations that I had. Indeed it was only in my early twenties following a great deal of rethinking and the guidance of some significant teachers that I began to sort myself out. Now many years later I believe that I am ready to refine what I have experienced and found useful to hopefully help others.

Breathing...Where it all begins.

Wind instrument playing all begins with a relaxed. efficient intake of air. Taken properly, utilising the greatest lung capacity available and dispensed under controlled pressure appropriate to the requirement of the instrument involved, an air stream is created that will energise an air column, then a reed or set of lips to do exactly what is desired for the musical execution of a phrase. Anything less that total control and execution will result in some level of musical loss - the air stream is that important.

When taking a breath the first stage is getting enough air into the lung quickly. Most tutors will advise opening the mouth, clearing the past of access to the throat, pushing out the abdominal muscles energetically and allowing air to 'rush in' to fill the void. Try standing or sitting in a well balanced position and work to expand your abdominal cavity in all directions: downwards, outwards, up to the bottom of the rib cage and at the back. I say to pupils that this is like trying to make oneself intentionally 'fat' with air.

If taken in successfully this large quantity of air will be held under pressure via the expanded 'stretched' position of the intercostal abdominal muscles for a brief period of time as you begin to release the air by blowing out. The challenge comes as the volume of air is reduced as you play. One must attempt to keep the air pressure constant while this loss of air is taking place by continuing to think of pushing the abdominal muscles 'out' - in other words keeping them engaged in the process of air support and not allowing them to merely collapse as the volume of air decreases. This is perhaps counter-intuitive but the action of attempting to 'compress' the abdominal muscles will only add tension to the process of blowing. Try taking a breath, beginning to speak and then, while speaking squeeze the abdominal muscles inwards. Your voice is likely to break or sound 'strangled' by this squeezing. Imagine what such undesirable tension could do to your instrumental tone!

Tongue and Oral Cavity Shape - Whistling

The shape that the player imparts to an air stream is another very important and altogether under appreciated aspect of tonal control. Many teachers speak of 'singing' via the instrument or illustrating good practice by using a series of vocalisations of various vowel sounds, i.e. Ahh, Eee,  Ooo, Ohhh. While this approach does work for some players I believe that it is not the most direct means of imparting an understanding of best practice positioning of the tongue. In my teaching I have found it more useful to suggest that a pupil first whistle for me - and notice the elevated position of the back of the tongue at the back of the top teeth and the position of the tip of the tongue near and behind the lower jaw front teeth. With the tongue in this position, blowing the air 'faster than you can sustain the whistle sound' is better illustration of an air stream shape suitable for most wind instrument blowing and well as providing a sense of the compression that must take place within the oral cavity. If a player is not familiar with or unable to whistle through the lips all is not lost. I like the following alternate approach: Imagine attempting to drink a very thick milkshake through a very weak straw. The aggressive 'sucking' position and sensitive 'drawn in' shape of the lips closely mirror a whistle position. Reverse the air flow to blowing instead of sucking and you are there!

When playing highly pitched instruments (i.e. Eb clarinet,  soprano sax, oboe, piccolo trumpet, etc.) or the higher regions of any instrument, the elevated part of tongue is best to be shaped high at the back of the oral cavity. As one performs on mid-pitch instruments or low-pitch instruments and lower ranges or pitch the 'focus' point of the tongue arch moves further forward in the oral cavity. Experimentation with this positioning can greatly aid the understanding involved in successfully 'doubling' between different size instruments i.e. oboe to cor anglais, flute to alto flute, Bb clarinet to bass clarinet, etc. and between different families, i.e. clarinet to saxophone, flute to bassoon, trumpet to trombone, etc.

'The Two Q's': Air Quantity and Quality

I firmly believe that the notion of how to deal with the variable column length and dimension of tubing that is fundamental to all wind instrument playing is vital and under appreciated. The concept of 'The Two Q's' is something that I have synthesised from many methods of trying to explain this elusive concept. The sensitivity of a player to the requirements of his or her instrument is vital to the development of instrumental control and this succinct summary will hopefully be both helpful and memorable:

• Players should always take care to supply the appropriate Quantity of air for whatever notes are being played, varying with the register, the volume being attempted, the length of the sounding tube, the type of attack being used and the timbre or expression sought.

• They must continually support and always use the best Quality of air that they can produce - this never varies and is the foundation of all beautiful playing. The degree of success one has in musical performance at all stages of learning is usually a direct indication of how well this principle has been understood and incorporated

 

 A Method of Practice

 

When faced with a phrase or section that contains many and various challenges to achieve the best possible musical expression many players resort to the repetitive practice of small sections, connecting up notes, addressing finger changes, experimenting with various dynamics, etc. This traditional approach is perfectly valid and often absolutely necessary. In addition I would like to propose a further practice option that in my experience is often overlooked. That is to play all or part of the phase(s) in question utilising at first a single pitch. This can be chosen from the phrase or completely unrelated. Within this sustained note one should try to express all the dynamic shape, control and duration of the original phrase. Once satisfied one can try introducing a selected series of note changes which begin to represent the phrase shape and challenges, perhaps the first notes of groupings or the extremes of interval leaps of the most dramatic of the required volume differentials - without sacrificing the overall control gained on the one sustained pitch. Once these intermediate stages have been successfully managed then work to add in further notes and/or finger changes until the entire phrase is being performed as intended.

If for instance an entire 4 bar phrase in a given tempo can be played with one breath using a sustained single pitch then the same 4 bar phrase should be able to be successfully played in the same tempo no matter how many subdivisions of notes are present or how wicked the intervals. If one struggles it is likely to be due to undesirable tension, less than ideal breath control or a lack of concentration while one is preoccupied with notes. Take a step back, practise the simplified phrase till confidence grows and then try again.

Very best wishes.

-----------------

The tips and comments above are the result of many years of providing help and advice, my personal interest and study, and the teaching that I have done during my career. I have many colleagues and teachers to thank for sharing their thoughts and suggestions on this and other topics. In addition I am indebted to Woodwind & Reed, Cambridge ( www.wwr.co.uk ) where, in the course of helping customers, many of these concepts have been refined and have proven helpful.


Thomas Dryer-Beers